Broken Prey


Associated Press
Marcus Eliason
May 6, 2005

In "Broken Prey," John Sandford delivers yet another blistering tale from the life of Lucas Davenport, surely one of the most attractive cops on the crime-fiction beat today.
After featuring hit women and Russian sleeper spies in his most recent "Prey" books, Sandford returns to the subject that launched the series: serial killers. This time, however, he offers not just one killer, but a whole slew of them, locked up in a Minnesota high-security ward as well as roaming free, and possibly in cahoots.
The novel opens with the discovery of a woman who has been tortured and killed. A week later another victim, a man, turns up, also grotesquely murdered. A suspect soon emerges, but the tangle has only just begun.
The plot is complex and full of red herrings. The cops are never quite sure whether they're being led astray by a charade cooked up by a truly ingenious and twisted mind. The insights into daily journalism – how it works and how police use it – come out of Sandford's own past as a newspaperman and are illuminating.
As usual, Sandford delivers strong procedural detail, a rich sense of Minnesota, and memorable secondary characters. Watch out for Gene Nordwall, the stolid, deeply human sheriff of Blue Earth County, whose walk-on part is memorable.
Several intriguing subplots add their sinew to the narrative. Sloan, Davenport's loyal partner, is contemplating retirement, much to Davenport's dismay. Sloan, a fine supporting "Prey" character, will be much missed if he indeed quits.
Then there's Davenport's agonizing effort to compile a list of the 100 greatest rock 'n' roll songs for the iPod his wife has bought him. The payoff for that subplot ends in quintessentially Davenportian style – unexpected, funny and just a little bit cruel.
Sandford's Web site, by the way, informs us that his novels are being reissued with new introductions. The first two introductions are already posted and make interesting reading. Go to http://www.johnsandford.org.



Booklist
Wes Lukowsky

The first victim is a young woman, probably flayed alive and raped. Lucas Davenport, head of Minnesota's Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, is assigned to the case by his boss, the governor, who fears political fallout if a serial killer is on the loose. A tip puts Davenport and his team on the trail of a recently paroled sexual offender. Charley Pope never killed anyone, but conventional wisdom indicates his rage may escalate. But the planning that went into the crimes seems to exceed Charley's capabilities. Lucas also entertains the possibility that Charley was a "robot" for three Hannibal Lector types in the asylum's high-security section for the criminally insane. The seventeenth Prey thriller is a cut above recent entries in the series. For one, it's a real whodunit, with the killer not revealed until the last couple chapters. Second, it contains supersized servings of all the elements readers have come to treasure in the series: Davenport's quirky, self-deprecating, and ironic worldview; plenty of graveyard humor; and a dynamic sense of place, from the Minnesota countryside to bustling Minneapolis to the foreboding gothic architecture of the asylum. An extra treat is Davenport's ongoing mental gyrations as he compiles a list of rock's 100 greatest tunes for his new iPod. His musical critiques are pure rock fan, and the final list is a hoot. Byzantine plot, memorable characters, and a subliminal soundtrack of classic rock 'n' roll. What's not to like?



Kirkus Reviews
March 15, 2005

Now that Lucas Davenport's gone up against a Russian spy ring (Hidden Prey, 2004), it's almost anticlimactic to ask him to catch a mere serial killer. But that's the only anticlimax here.
What are the odds that the M.O. behind Angela Larson's murder – she was bound, scourged with a wire whip, and repeatedly raped before her throat was cut and her body laid out in a ritualistic display – would be repeated with a male victim? But Adam Rice, an old acquaintance of Blue Earth County sheriff Gene Nordwall's, presents the same grisly picture. Was their killer gay or bisexual? How did he find his victims? And what do they have in common? Lucas, who runs the Office of Regional Research for the Minnesota's Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, is all over the case, amassing evidence against Charlie Pope, a sex offender just released from St. John's Security Hospital with a few months to run on his sentence but his attitude still intact. Charlie has celebrated his freedom by sawing off his ankle monitor and vanishing – except for the trace evidence he's left at the crime scenes and the phone calls he makes, first to ambitious Star-Tribune reporter Ruffe Ignace, then to Lucas himself. The only trouble is that Charlie's clearly not smart enough to be the murderer. He must be getting help from somebody – maybe from one of the habitual Big Three offenders he spent time with at St. John's. Wondering whether anybody not named Hannibal Lecter can be issuing murderous instructions from inside a prison, Lucas and Co. hunker down to take a long hard look at the hospital just as things start to get really interesting.
A tale so fast-moving you won't even notice the unobtrusively expert detective work till the second time around.



Publishers Weekly

Sandford sends series hero Lucas Davenport's family off to London to ensure that domestic concerns never slow the action in this sexy, bloody thriller. Davenport, a Minnesota State Bureau of Criminal Apprehension investigator, had lately been doing political fix-it jobs for the governor, but this time he's got a psychopathic serial killer on his hands. ("All major metro areas had them, sometimes two and three at a time. The public had the impression that they were rare. They weren't.") The first victim, a young woman, was "scourged" with a wire whip; number two, a young man, had his penis cut off. Evidence first points to recently released sex offender Charlie Pope. Though Charlie is pretty dumb and the killer is extremely smart, it takes Davenport and his series partner, Detective Sloan, a while to realize they're chasing the wrong guy. Sandford introduces some lighter moments, the most entertaining about Davenport's new iPod and his quest to compile a list of the 100 best rock songs ever recorded, which every cop on the force gives him suggestions for. These moments allow readers to catch their breath amid the otherwise nonstop tension as the killer taunts the authorities while snaring more victims, and the cops race around the countryside always just a few minutes too late. For those who thought Davenport (and Sandford) were slowing down and showing signs of age and prosperity, this superlative entry will dispel all such notions. This is tough, unstoppable, white-knuckle fiction.